Lately, I’ve seen a lot of frustration around influencers. Brands and marketers complain about their high rates, the lack of tangible results, or simply walk away, feeling like the investment wasn’t worth it. But let’s get one thing straight—the problem isn’t the influencers themselves. The real issue? Many brands don’t have a proper influencer strategy in place.
Where Brands Go Wrong with Influencers
The biggest mistake brands make when working with influencers is not understanding how to measure success. They jump into collaborations without clear goals, tracking mechanisms, or a way to calculate the return on investment (ROI). Here’s where things typically fall apart:
-
No Clear Success Metrics
What does success look like? Is it brand awareness, engagement, conversions, or direct sales? Too often, brands don’t define this upfront, making it impossible to gauge whether a campaign worked.
-
No Proper Tracking Tools
If you’re relying only on likes and comments, you’re missing the bigger picture. Brands need to track link clicks, conversions, and customer acquisition costs to truly understand impact.
-
Lack of ROI Calculation
Even when brands do measure some level of success, they often struggle to translate that into an ROI calculation. If you don’t know how much revenue an influencer-driven campaign is generating compared to the cost, how do you justify future spending?
Influencers Need to Sell More Than Just Their Followers
On the flip side, if brands are walking away from influencers and the only takeaway is that their pricing was too high, then the influencer has also failed in a key area—demonstrating their value. An influencer’s biggest selling point isn’t just their follower count—it’s their audience and how they can leverage that audience for brand success.
Influencers Should Answer These Key Questions:
- How will working with me help you achieve X business goal?
- What kind of ROI can you expect from a campaign with me?
- How do I position my audience in a way that makes sense for your brand?
It’s Not Just About Hooks and Aesthetics
A lot of social media experts talk about having the right hook, perfecting your content format, or following the latest trend. While these things matter, they aren’t enough. If an influencer can’t speak the language of brands and articulate the business value they bring, they’ll struggle to secure meaningful partnerships.
How Brands Can Fix Their Influencer Strategy
If you’re a brand looking to maximize your influencer partnerships, here’s what you need to do:
- Set Clear Goals – Are you looking for brand awareness, engagement, leads, or conversions? Define your success metrics upfront.
- Use the Right Tools – Leverage tracking links, promo codes, and analytics platforms to measure influencer performance.
- Calculate ROI – Don’t just spend money blindly. Use a formula that considers influencer fees, engagement rates, and direct revenue impact.
Want to take it a step further? Use our Influencer ROI Calculator to estimate the value an influencer can bring to your brand.
Ready to Get More Out of Influencer Marketing?
If you want to refine your influencer strategy and drive actual business results, let’s talk. Our team specializes in crafting influencer campaigns that work—meaning they bring measurable ROI, not just vanity metrics.
